Sacked Ukrainian judge rejects dismissal as illegal

11:37, 03 May 2007
742 0

Yushchenko dismissed Stanik "for breaching the oath"

Syuzanna Stanik [former judge of the Constitutional Court of Ukraine] has said that her dismissal was illegal, according to NTN television report, translated by the BBC Monitoring Service.

On 1 May, President Viktor Yushchenko signed a decree dismissing Stanik from her post "for breaching the oath".

Speaking in an exclusive interview with NTN, she said that she did not breach the oath.

The president`s decree of 1 May dismissing her lacks the observance of a necessary procedure because, according to the law on the Constitutional Court and the court`s procedures, the issue of breaching the oath should first be considered by a special commission which should forward its conclusions to the Supreme Council [parliament].

Article 126 of the constitution, which the president referred to, says that judges can be dismissed by the body which appointed them.

Stanik said: “The law on the Constitutional Court has a clear provision which says that the issue of a judge breaching the oath should be considered by the Supreme Council.

This is why, speaking or thinking about the decree, I arrived at a very  simple conclusion: whether the president of Ukraine has the right to  interpret the constitution and the laws of Ukraine. Our country`s laws say  he cannot. Article 150 of the Constitution of Ukraine grants such a right only to the Constitutional Court of Ukraine.”

This news was monitored by the Action Ukraine Monitoring Service for the Action Ukraine Report (AUR), Morgan Williams, SigmaBleyzer, Editor. 

If you see a spelling error on our site, select it and press Ctrl+Enter